Christy Clark to lose her own seat in May 14 BC general election?

February 4, 2013 | By | 2 Replies More

BC Liberals need Christy Clark all over the province, not stuck in Vancouver-Point Grey

christy clark

BC Premier Christy Clark may be in trouble in her own riding on May 14. File photo.

Bruce A. Stewart  

When it comes to polls, Mustel makes the BC Liberal brain trust happy, and Angus-Reid makes them miserable.

Either way, though, they’re not close enough to Adrian Dix and his BC NDP as less than one hundred days await until British Columbians vote.

Seats that normally would come home to the Liberals without working up a sweat will, this time, require a knock-down, drag-out fight to win. Visits (as in plural) by the Premier Christy Clark to whoop it up with the local candidate will matter — a lot.


Dear Beacon readers. Please help us serve you better by filling out this brief survey form. We thank you for your feedback and your commitment to local online news.


But there’s only one problem with that.

Christy Clark Clark barely eked out a win in Vancouver-Point Grey in the by-election of 2011 that allowed her to replace Gordon Campbell in his seat (after replacing him as the leader of the party). Her opponent, NDP candidate David Eby of the Pivot Legal Society, came very close to claiming the seat (as the New Democrats broke with grabbing a UBC type for this riding that includes the campus).

Eby is running against Clark again in the rematch. He’s already working the riding hard. And soundings on the ground show that Christy Clark Clark is either in an outright tie (best case interpretation) or coming from behind (worst case interpretation).

Either way, she can’t just count on her own personal race as “home and dry”, leaving her free to campaign for others around the province.

The BC Liberals have banked everything in this campaign on Christy Clark Clark.

Take a look at the party’s logo: if you just glance at it, the red letters in bold — BC and Christy — far outweigh the lighter weight blue letters of Liberal and Clark.

In other words, it’s the BC Christy party that’s being put forward.

Which, of course, is perfectly reasonable. She has the name recognition to try and help turn the tide in other ridings.

(Given, too, how many BC Liberal supporters are also federal Conservative supporters, and given that this time there’ll be BC Conservative candidates on most ballot papers in the province — they contested less than fifteen per cent of the seats in 2009 — any reminder to “vote Christy” is probably a good one.)

One of Clark’s problems, though, is that so much of her core team isn’t running for re-election.

A Kevin Falcon, for instance, could have been all over British Columbia helping backstop the party. But he’s standing down (and waiting in the wings to see Christy implode before deciding how permanent his exit is). Christy Clark Clark won’t have that kind of support: she’ll get, at best, an appearance or two (and probably close to home).

Vancouver-Point Grey, meanwhile, will be a different kind of challenge for Clark.

Effectively, it’s only residents of the riding who will be voting: the university is between sessions in May. Any residual students will be finishing up exams or frantically marking them throughout the campaign period — there’ll be little opportunity to get supporters to door knock, or vote early for Christy Clark Clark (early ballots were what saved her in her by-election run two years ago).

Eby, meanwhile, remains a well-known figure, and not just because he’s a common figure in the media on behalf of his work for Pivot Legal.

Eby has spent the past few years questioning decisions that have directly affected the voters of Vancouver-Point Grey, such as the sheer number of dedicated bike lanes (affecting traffic out of the riding into the central city) Vancouver City Council has built.

Choked streets like Point Grey Rd. and Cornwall Ave. may technically be a municipal problem, not a provincial problem, but residents only care that someone seems to feel their pain.

Unfortunately, when it comes to tapping into local issues, Clark can be a little tone-deaf. (She was equally so in her earlier stint in the legislature as the MLA for Port Moody-Westwood in the early 2000s: then, being Deputy Premier and Education Minister far outranked the concerns of her Port Moody and Coquitlam electors.)

In this, Christy Clark Clark is not unlike other senior figures in governments around the country, except that she’s following in Gordon Campbell’s footsteps. He, despite being Premier, found the time to be around the riding, talking with residents, handling their issues.

Perception is reality in politics, and the perception is that Clark doesn’t care the way Campbell did, and that Eby does.

For all that the polls are tending toward Clark losing her riding (and government) on May 14, it’s certainly true that the BC Liberals will pour resources from other ridings into Vancouver-Point Grey. Vancouver-Quilchena next door, for instance, has been a very safe Liberal seat for years.

But other seats nearby are also in trouble. Margaret MacDairmid, the health minister, in Vancouver-Fairview (which borders both Point Grey and Quilchena) is in deep trouble, running against George Heyman, the former head of the BC Goverment Employees’ Union and Executive Director of the Sierra Club of BC. (This is the riding current Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson represented for the BC NDP, defeating MacDairmid before leaving to municipal politics.) Others that were safer last time, like Vancouver-False Creek, will be in greater contention this time around, with less to spare to neighbouring ridings.

Christy Clark is needed everywhere in BC, and yet there’s little margin for error back home.

Clark’s problem is that even if the party loses, it needs to avoid the potential blowout scenario (as happened to the NDP in 2001, where they had only two seats against all Liberals). Saving seats all over BC — and most of the “winnables” are well outside the Lower Mainland, where campaigning for others and at home would be possible — is mandatory.

Ninety-nine days to election day, and the clock is ticking for Christy Clark in more ways than one.


Tags: , ,

Category: British Columbia

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Raifon says:

    She should run in a secure location like Ottawa !

  2. Jean says:

    I would like to know what Christy Clark is going to do to help the multitude of people who hold medical marijuana licences, and need them and if they lose them will have to go underground again to obtain the product they need at great cost. Alot of people have spent alot of money to obtain a place to legally grow with other people and what will happen to them then, they pay hydro they dont steal it. they just want to be able to move and be pain free, and dont tell me it doesnt work because i was a non believer but started juicing and i feel way better than i have in years, doctors just dont understand. So Christy Clark what are you going to do to help me and the rest of the people in BC who dont want to break the law and want to be able to move without pain everyday. You want to move forward help us be able to do that to

Leave a Reply

Tell your Story