Community potato venture pits volunteers against Ward 8 alderman Mar

May 21, 2012 | By | 23 Replies More

Potatoes for People may face trespassing charges

Potatoes for People volunteers working in the vacant lot on 17 Ave. S.W. Photo: Donna Clarke.

By Markham Hislop         

Alderman John Mar is coming under fire from residents in Ward 8 for his role in attempts to shut down a community potato growing effort on 17 Ave. S.W.

Sunday afternoon, police and bylaw officers arrived at a vacant lot where local residents calling themselves Potatoes for the People had gathered to plant potatoes in an effort to spruce up the area and provide food for the Inter-faith Food Bank and the Calgary Drop In Centre.

Organizer Donna Clarke says Mar was a passenger in one of the police vans. When she walked over to introduce herself, she says Mar wasn’t interested in talking to her about the project. In fact, she says he never left the vehicle during the time she was being warned by police that she had 24 hours to remove her potato-growing equipment, which consisted of brightly painted tires and plants.

“John Mar is the city councillor for this area and this is his response to people trying to improve the neighbourhood,” said Clarke.



Mar acknowledges that he called police about what he thought might be people drinking or using drugs. He says he knows the land is privately owned and the people he saw likely didn’t have permission to be there. Police initially had trouble finding the lot, so Mar volunteered to ride along and show them.

He says he was happy to shake Clarke’s hand, but didn’t feel his obligations extended beyond saying hello.

“I was actually then in a meeting with the authorities. I don’t know why if I’m doing something else I don’t have a moment to learn about her project that’s on someone else’s land,” said Mar.

Mar is a former member of the RCMP and says he is concerned about safety issues within the ward, which encompasses much of the downtown core and beltline district. Clarke and the Potatoes for the People volunteers were trespassing, he says, and did not apply to City Hall for permits or advise the City that they intended to occupy the lot.

“The issue here is strictly that they chose to do it (planting potatoes) on land that doesn’t belong to them,” he said.

Fence painted by Potatoes for the People volunteers. Photo: Donna Clarke.

Clarke doesn’t see why such a big deal is being made of planting a few potatoes on a vacant lot, regardless of who owns it (she believes it belongs to a bank, but neither she nor Mar could confirm the identity of the owner). She says the lot is next door to her house and over the past few years has grown tired of seeing nothing done with the property.

“The soil is not ideal so I thought that potatoes would be ideal to repair the soil. There is room for lots and lots of potatoes,” she wrote on the Facebook page she set up to promote the project.

Bylaw officers issued Clarke a notice ordering her to remove “accumulation of prohibited material or garbage.” She takes issue with the characterization of the tires and potato plants as garbage.

“These are beautifully painted tires…there are pictures of the property before and after, and before we started painting the tires, this was not garbage that was accumulating,” she said.

Calgary is a big supporter of community gardens and urban agriculture, including providing funds, said Mar, and Clarke is welcome to apply to start one on an approved area, which includes City-owned property. There are already several community gardens in the ward and the two-term alderman says he would like to see more.

Clarke says City Hall bureaucracy and red tape are onerous for a small group of community volunteers, and that starting a community garden doesn’t solve the problem she set out to tackle in the first place, the improvement of the eyesore next door to her house.

In addition to painting tires to hold the potato plants, Clarke and her volunteers also repaired and painted a fence on the property. She says 40 to 50 area residents stopped by to admire the group’s handiwork and express their support.

“I don’t want to hide it in someone’s yard. It’s about growing community and reclaiming derelict spaces. It’s not about hiding an individual initiative, it’s about community initiative,” said Clarke. “And the response is a crackdown from City Hall.”

Even if Clarke removes the tires and avoids the bylaw infraction, she may be facing a stiffer penalty. Duty Inspector Mike Tillotson confirmed that the Calgary Police Service will be contacting the property’s owner to determine if they want to press trespassing charges, which is standard procedure when someone has unlawfully entered a property.




Category: Calgary

Comments (23)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Some Dude says:

    John Mar is a loser and a coward. “Meeting with authorities”? He brought them there to piss on a community garden, and then essentially spat upon the person responsible for the endeavor’s hand (one of his CONSTITUENTS nonetheless).

    I hope he forever remains a two-term alderman.

  2. Vi Gerbrandt says:

    I believe that Alderman Mar is cowardly and not doing his duty as an Alderman, when he snubbed the organizer of this project (which, by the way certainly does do good for the community, as well as beautifies the abandoned property.) It this property is owned by a bank, or anyone else, it is the public’s right to know who does own the property, so as to put the pressure on for empty spaces to be used responsibly. Instead of giving these community minded individuals tickets – the owner of the property could be approached by the city of Calgary (and John Mar could have taken the initiative to assist in that process), to then get permission to have this wonderful, creative and helpful venture on this property.

    Is Alderman Mar as concerned about the behaviors of the many, many patrons to the Calgary Stampede each year who violate the residents of Calgary with obnoxious behaviors and treatment of the poor in the City?? I think not. In fact, some years ago, the Calgary Police service (not sure if the RCMP was in on it), wanted have a tent during stampede time, where they could sell liqour for profit. As someone who is fully aware of how much of the confiscated liqour is consumed by the police at the Cuff ‘n Billy (I have witnessed it myself when invited to the ‘Other Policeman’s Ball’ by a co-worker and her police husband). The manner in which the confiscated liqour is dealt with should be a matter for the public to be concerned about, as this theft from the public, some of which is then consumed by the police – SHOULD BE SOMETHING ALDERMAN WARD SHOULD GET ON RIGHT AWAY. It is the city’s 100 year celebration of the Calgary Stampede – so he should be welcoming community projects to assist the hungry – and making sure the behaviors of the already tainted reputation that the authorities have – is cleaned up. So – how about judging and dealing with the behaviors of those in uniform instead, Alderman Ward?? As a former employee of AADAC, I witnessed many occasions of police and politicians ‘conduct’ with drugs and alcohol. Please put the attention where it belongs – cleaning up the corrupt system, Alderman Mar – not picking on the people who do good in the community – with meager, but friendly means.

  3. Vi Gerbrandt says:

    I would like to correct something from my note above – toward the end of it. The part I wrote in Caps should read: ” The manner in which the confiscated liqour is dealt with should be a matter for the public to be concerned about, as this theft from the public, some of which is then consumed by the police – SHOULD BE SOMETHING ALDERMAN MAR SHOULD GET ON RIGHT AWAY.” Perhaps a typo was OK – as this suggestion is very valid, in how the energy of Alderman Mar could be constructively used in serving his constituents – not harassing those who do good – especially on a voluntary basis.

Leave a Reply

Tell your Story